Listening to Donald Trump or his top aides, one might think his second term has already rewritten the history books. Trump regularly touts soaring tariff revenue, low gas prices, and rapid progress on his agenda to strengthen the nation, presenting his leadership as both transformative and unmatched.

Critics, however, argue that this narrative relies heavily on exaggeration and selective facts. Trump’s presidency remains one of the most polarizing in modern U.S. history, and many members of his administration have closely tied their political fortunes to his. As a result, the upbeat picture coming from the White House often contrasts sharply with public sentiment beyond it.

That divide has only grown since Trump returned to office last January. He has moved swiftly to expand executive authority and push sweeping policy changes, energizing his supporters while deepening concerns among opponents. Trump portrays himself as a force for global stability, claiming credit for avoiding new conflicts, yet some of his rhetoric and actions—ranging from comments about Venezuela’s leadership to renewed talk of acquiring Greenland—have struck critics as confrontational or overreaching.

Domestic issues have added to the debate. His hardline stance on immigration continues to draw scrutiny, as do lingering controversies linked to his name. Taken together, these factors have made it difficult for skeptics to believe that Trump’s popularity has significantly improved during his second term.

Recent polling supports that view. An AP-NORC survey conducted this month shows a nation still deeply divided. About 40 percent of U.S. adults say they approve of Trump’s job performance, while roughly 59 percent disapprove—a balance that has remained largely unchanged since early 2025.

Approval ratings by issue tell a similar story. Fewer than four in ten respondents approve of Trump’s handling of the economy, immigration, foreign policy, or trade, with clear majorities expressing disapproval in each area.

Overall, the numbers suggest that despite Trump’s confident claims of success, his second term has not sparked a broad surge in public support. He continues to command loyalty from his base and dominate political conversation, but most Americans remain unconvinced by his leadership. For now, the gap between Trump’s self-described achievements and public opinion remains a defining feature of his presidency.